Rooftop solar increases electricity use, raising questions for utilities and policymakers

According to a caller investigation by researchers astatine Georgia Tech's Ivan Allen College of Liberal Arts, homeowners who instal star panels upwind up utilizing much energy than earlier going green, a uncovering that could person implications for vigor readying and clime alteration mitigation efforts.

The survey by Daniel Matisoff and Ross Beppler of the School of Public Policy, and Matthew Oliver of the School of Economics, recovered that astir a 3rd of the energy generated by solar power customers of 1 eastbound U.S. inferior went to accrued energy usage. This dulls the energy savings and carbon offsets greenish vigor advocates anticipation to spot from star and different renewable energies.

The findings, published online Oct. 4 successful Economic Inquiry, are important for inferior planners and public officials trying to gauge however champion to responsibly incentivize star adoption amid a increasing telephone to trim U.S. greenhouse state emissions successful the look of dire clime alteration warnings.

"More and more, states are efficaciously providing subsidies for consumers to instal rooftop star connected their homes," said Matisoff. "This survey is simply a measurement toward helping policymakers recognize if the investments they are making successful encouraging the enlargement of star vigor are worthy the cost."

The researchers recovered that portion star procreation accounted for astir 56% of what customers utilized earlier installing rooftop panels, the gully connected the power grid dropped by lone 40% afterward. Compare that to different customers of the aforesaid inferior who didn't instal star and whose energy depletion remained unchanged.

The 28% quality betwixt the 2 numbers is what economists telephone a "rebound effect." Traditionally, specified an effect occurs erstwhile expected gains from vigor efficiencies are mislaid to accrued consumption. One example: When idiosyncratic buys a caller fuel-efficient car, past drives much due to the fact that their per-mile outgo of substance has dropped. They extremity up partially offsetting the gains policymakers mightiness person expected successful presumption of little substance consumption.

"The cardinal quality with installing star is that it has thing to bash with vigor ratio arsenic we usually deliberation of it," Oliver said. "Rather, the rebound effect occurs arsenic a effect to the availability of star power, a substitute for grid-supplied energy that is fundamentally escaped aft incurring the outgo of the strategy installation itself."

Other studies person recovered rebound effects from star energy. What sets the Georgia Tech survey isolated is that it is the archetypal to usage nonstop billing information from the full lawsuit basal of a utility—about 500,000 customers, including 8,000 star customers. It besides is constructed to supply amended penetration into what is driving the accrued consumption, Matisoff said.

The Georgia Tech uncovering of a 28% rebound effect is besides much important than different studies, which person recovered an effect of betwixt 11% and 20%.

"What these findings constituent to is that radical were antecedently suppressing immoderate of their energy usage due to the fact that they felt atrocious astir the emissions," helium said. "Because the star vigor is greener, they consciousness a motivation licence to usage more."

Another explanation, Matisoff said, could beryllium that erstwhile consumers power to star power, they sometimes besides power to electric-powered vehicles, h2o heaters, and different appliances to instrumentality vantage of their new, cleaner vigor source.

That's not needfully an biology problem—at slightest not now, Matisoff said. But it does airs questions for utilities. A important rebound effect tied to rooftop star volition impact wide powerfulness request and effect successful complications for powerfulness procreation planning, management, and reliability, according to the authors. Such issues are not insignificant erstwhile you see that forecasters expect star powerfulness installations to turn to 8,000GW and supply 6% of planetary energy by 2050, according to the International Renewable Energy Agency.

"The important penetration is that 1 gigawatt of caller residential star gets you considerably little than a 1-gigawatt simplification successful request for powerfulness provided by accepted sources," Oliver said. "An close estimation of that rebound effect has to beryllium built into forecasts of electricity request if the powerfulness strategy is going to accommodate efficiently to the continued proliferation of this technology."

The results besides should punctual policymakers to deliberation astir whether subsidies are decently tuned to the payment they provide, Matisoff said.

"If we're spending nationalist dollars to offset ember oregon gas, we request to cognize however overmuch of the star procreation we're subsidizing offsets dirtier energy, and however overmuch is caller consumption," Matisoff said.

---

---

More information: Ross C. Beppler et al, Electricity depletion changes pursuing star adoption: Testing for a star rebound, Economic Inquiry (2021). DOI: 10.1111/ecin.13031