People or profit? Facebook papers show deep conflict within

Facebook the institution is losing power of Facebook the product—not to notation the past shreds of its cautiously crafted, decade-old representation arsenic a benevolent institution conscionable wanting to link the world.

Thousands of pages of interior documents provided to Congress by a erstwhile worker picture an internally conflicted institution wherever information connected the harms it causes is abundant, but solutions, overmuch little the volition to enactment connected them, are halting astatine best.

The situation exposed by the documents shows however Facebook, contempt its regularly avowed good intentions, appears to person slow-walked oregon sidelined efforts to code existent harms the societal web has magnified and sometimes created. They uncover galore instances wherever researchers and rank-and-file workers uncovered deep-seated problems that the institution past overlooked oregon ignored.

Final work for this authorities of affairs rests with CEO Mark Zuckerberg, who holds what 1 erstwhile worker described arsenic dictatorial powerfulness implicit a corp that collects information connected and provides escaped services to astir 3 cardinal radical astir the world.

"Ultimately, it rests with Mark and immoderate his prerogative is—and it has ever been to grow, to summation his powerfulness and his reach," said Jennifer Grygiel, a Syracuse University communications prof who's followed Facebook intimately for years.

Zuckerberg has an ironclad clasp connected Facebook Inc. He holds the bulk of the company's voting shares, controls its committee of directors and has progressively surrounded himself with executives who don't look to question his vision.

But helium has truthful acold been incapable to code stagnating idiosyncratic maturation and shrinking engagement for Facebook the merchandise successful cardinal areas specified arsenic the United States and Europe. Worse, the institution is losing the attraction of its astir important demographic—teenagers and young people—with nary wide way to gaining it back, its ain documents reveal.

Young adults prosecute with Facebook acold little than their older cohorts, seeing it arsenic an "outdated network" with "irrelevant content" that provides constricted worth for them, according to a November 2020 interior document. It is "boring, misleading and negative," they say.

In different words, the young spot Facebook arsenic a spot for aged people.

Facebook's idiosyncratic basal has been aging faster, connected average, than the wide population, the company's researchers found. Unless Facebook tin find a mode to crook this around, its colonisation volition proceed to get older and young radical volition find adjacent less reasons to motion on, threatening the monthly idiosyncratic figures that are indispensable to selling ads. Facebook says its products are inactive wide utilized by teens, though it acknowledges there's "tough competition" from TikTok, Snapchat and the like.

So it tin proceed to grow its scope and power, Facebook has pushed for precocious idiosyncratic maturation extracurricular the U.S. and Western Europe. But arsenic it expanded into little acquainted parts of the world, the institution systematically failed to code oregon adjacent expect the unintended consequences of signing up millions of caller users without besides providing unit and systems to place and bounds the dispersed of hatred speech, misinformation and calls to violence.

In Afghanistan and Myanmar, for instance, extremist connection has flourished owed to a systemic deficiency of connection enactment for contented moderation, whether that's quality oregon artificial intelligence-driven. In Myanmar, it has been linked to atrocities committed against the country's number Rohingya Muslim population.

But Facebook appears incapable to acknowledge, overmuch little prevent, the real-world collateral harm accompanying its untrammeled growth. Those harms see shadowy algorithms that radicalize users, pervasive misinformation and extremism, facilitation of quality trafficking, teen termination and more.

Internal efforts to mitigate specified problems person often been pushed speech oregon abandoned erstwhile solutions struggle with growth—and, by extension, profit.

Backed into a country with hard grounds from leaked documents, the institution has doubled down defending its choices alternatively than effort to hole its problems.

"We bash not and we person not prioritized engagement implicit safety," Monika Bickert, Facebook's caput of planetary argumentation management, told The Associated Press this period pursuing legislature grounds from whistleblower and erstwhile Facebook worker Frances Haugen. In the days since Haugen's grounds and quality connected "60 Minutes"—during which Zuckerberg posted a video of himself sailing with his woman Priscilla Chan—Facebook has tried to discredit Haugen by repeatedly pointing retired that she didn't straight enactment connected galore of the problems she revealed.

"A curated enactment retired of millions of documents astatine Facebook tin successful nary mode beryllium utilized to gully just conclusions astir us," Facebook tweeted from its nationalist relations "newsroom" relationship earlier this month, pursuing the company's find that a radical of quality organizations was moving connected stories astir the interior documents.

"At the bosom of these stories is simply a premise which is false. Yes, we're a concern and we marque profit, but the thought that we bash truthful astatine the disbursal of people's information oregon wellbeing misunderstands wherever our ain commercialized interests lie," Facebook said successful a prepared connection Friday. "The information is we've invested $13 cardinal and person implicit 40,000 radical to bash 1 job: support radical harmless connected Facebook."

Statements similar these are the latest motion that Facebook has gotten into what Sophie Zhang, a erstwhile Facebook information scientist, described arsenic a "siege mentality" astatine the company. Zhang past twelvemonth accused the societal web of ignoring fake accounts utilized to undermine overseas elections. With more whistleblowers—notably Haugen—coming forward, it's lone gotten worse.

"Facebook has been going done a spot of an authoritarian communicative spiral, wherever it becomes little responsive to worker criticism, to interior dissent and successful immoderate cases cracks down upon it," said Zhang, who was fired from Facebook successful the autumn of 2020. "And this leads to much interior dissent."

"I person seen galore colleagues that are highly frustrated and angry, portion astatine the aforesaid time, feeling powerless and (disheartened) astir the existent situation," 1 employee, whose sanction was redacted, wrote connected an interior connection committee aft Facebook decided past twelvemonth to permission up incendiary posts by erstwhile President Donald Trump that suggested Minneapolis protesters could beryllium shot. "My presumption is, if you privation to hole Facebook, bash it within."

This communicative is based successful portion connected disclosures made to the Securities and Exchange Commission and provided to Congress successful redacted signifier by Haugen's ineligible counsel. The redacted versions received by Congress were obtained by a consortium of quality organizations, including The Associated Press.

They item painstakingly collected information connected problems arsenic wide-ranging arsenic the trafficking of home workers successful the Middle East, an over-correction successful crackdowns connected Arabic content that critics accidental muzzles escaped code portion hatred code and maltreatment flourish, and rampant anti-vaccine misinformation that researchers recovered could person been easy tamped down with subtle changes successful however users presumption posts connected their feed.

The institution insists it "does not behaviour probe and past systematically and willfully disregard it if the findings are inconvenient for the company." This claim, Facebook said successful a statement, tin "only beryllium made by cherry-picking selective quotes from idiosyncratic pieces of leaked worldly successful a mode that presents analyzable and nuanced issues arsenic if determination is lone ever 1 close answer."

• In this Oct. 17, 2018, record photo, a emblem of the United State is shown betwixt monitors arsenic workers beryllium astatine their desks during a objection successful the warfare room, wherever Facebook monitors predetermination related contented connected the platform, successful Menlo Park, Calif. From complaints whistleblower Frances Haugen has filed with the SEC, on with redacted interior documents obtained by The Associated Press, the representation of the mighty Facebook that emerges is of a troubled, internally conflicted company, wherever information connected the harms it causes is abundant, but solutions are halting astatine best. Credit: AP Photo/Jeff Chiu, File

• This Aug. 11, 2019, record photograph an iPhone displays the apps for Facebook and Messenger successful New Orleans. From complaints whistleblower Frances Haugen has filed with the SEC, on with redacted interior documents obtained by The Associated Press, the representation of the mighty Facebook that emerges is of a troubled, internally conflicted company, wherever information connected the harms it causes is abundant, but solutions are halting astatine best. Credit: AP Photo/Jenny Kane, File

• In this May 9, 2019, record photo, protesters, wearing "angry emoticon" masks picket the Facebook bureau successful the state to protestation Facebook's alleged inaction against fake news, hatred code and red-tagging oregon vilification run of wellness activists, successful suburban Taguig metropolis eastbound of Manila, Philippines. From complaints whistleblower Frances Haugen has filed with the SEC, on with redacted interior documents obtained by The Associated Press, the representation of the mighty Facebook that emerges is of a troubled, internally conflicted company, wherever information connected the harms it causes is abundant, but solutions are halting astatine best. Credit: AP Photo/Bullit Marquez, File

• In this April 14, 2020, record photo, the thumbs up "Like" logo is shown connected a motion astatine Facebook office successful Menlo Park, Calif., USA. From complaints whistleblower Frances Haugen has filed with the SEC, on with redacted interior documents obtained by The Associated Press, the representation of the mighty Facebook that emerges is of a troubled, internally conflicted company, wherever information connected the harms it causes is abundant, but solutions are halting astatine best. Credit: AP Photo/Jeff Chiu, File

Haugen, who testified earlier the Senate this period that Facebook's products "harm children, stoke part and weaken our democracy," said the institution should state "moral bankruptcy" if it is to determination guardant from each this.

At this stage, that seems unlikely. There is simply a deep-seated struggle betwixt nett and radical wrong Facebook—and the institution does not look to beryllium acceptable to springiness up connected its communicative that it's bully for the satellite adjacent arsenic it regularly makes decisions intended to maximize growth.

"Facebook did regular surveys of its employees—what percent of employees judge that Facebook is making the satellite a amended place," Zhang recalled.

"It was astir 70 percent erstwhile I joined. It was astir 50 percent erstwhile I left," said Zhang, who was astatine the company for much than 2 years earlier she was fired successful the autumn of 2020.

Facebook has not said wherever the fig stands today.

---

---

© 2021 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This worldly whitethorn not beryllium published, broadcast, rewritten oregon redistributed without permission.