How Black Twitter has become the new 'Green Book,' and more

In 1936 successful Harlem, New York, a Black postal idiosyncratic named Victor Green bound unneurotic a green, 15-page booklet listing New York City businesses that were welcoming to African Americans.

In the coming decades, The Negro Motorist Green Book, a.k.a. The Green Book, expanded to see everything from hotels and restaurants to authorities parks and barbershops, with editions arsenic acold distant arsenic Bermuda and Mexico providing guidance connected however to defy favoritism and threats of violence.

Green discontinued the usher successful 1966, aft the transition of the Civil Rights Act presumably rendered its contented obsolete.

But much than a half-century later, a modern-day mentation is flourishing successful the online assemblage of Black Twitter, suggests caller CU Boulder research.

"The Green Book was designed to assistance Black radical navigate a racist society, and unluckily we inactive beryllium successful a racist society," said pb writer Shamika Klassen, a Ph.D. campaigner successful the Department of Information Science. "Black Twitter, similar The Green Book, provides a almighty abstraction successful which Black radical tin stock tips and experiences astir navigating it."

For the study, presented Oct. 26 astatine CSCW 2021 (the yearly league connected Computer Supported Cooperative Work and Social Computing), Klassen and colleagues astatine CU arsenic good arsenic Carnegie Mellon and Harvard universities collected much than 75,000 tweets from April and May of 2020.

They besides conducted 18 in-depth interviews with Black Twitter users.

Their investigation shines a airy connected the captious relation the informal online abstraction has played during the pandemic and radical unrest of caller years. It besides exposes flaws that sometimes wounded its users.

"Social media successful wide has been built by and mostly for achromatic people," said elder writer Casey Fiesler, an adjunct prof of Information Science, who is white. "With Black Twitter, radical person worked wrong 1 of those platforms, taking ownership of it to make a web of resistance, economical empowerment and Black joy. It's remarkable."

What is Black Twitter?

Just who coined the word Black Twitter is simply a substance of immoderate uncertainty, but articles began to notation the emergence of a "strong, connected Black community" connected Twitter astir 2008, erstwhile the hashtag #uknowurblackwhen went viral.

In the aftermath of the 2013 fatal shooting decease of Trayvon Martin, writer Feminista Jones referred to "Black Twitter" arsenic the "underground railroad of activism."

"140 characters tin beryllium each it takes to spark a movement," she wrote successful Salon.

In coming years, Blacktags (hashtags relating to Black identity) similar #BlackLivesMatter and #DrivingWhileBlack became a rallying outcry for radical justice. And erstwhile the pandemic hit, #COVIDWhileBlack spurred conversations astir inequities successful wellness care.

Black Twitter is not a abstracted level but alternatively an "open concealed waiting successful plain show for those who cognize however to find it," said Klassen.

Mostly Black users (and immoderate non-Black allies) find each different via often elusive hashtags related to a shared Black experience.

"Black identity, Black history, Black culture, joyousness and symptom each premix unneurotic to make this acquisition that is Black Twitter," says Klassen.

Users trust connected it, overmuch similar they did The Green Book, to question retired recommendations for everything from nail technicians and hairsbreadth braiders to Black-owned vineyards and restaurants. But they besides usage it to telephone retired racist businesses, zoning and lodging laws, celebrities oregon politicians.

Some show it for guidance connected governmental activism: "I cognize erstwhile I spell to take, you know, a state mask, bring h2o for people, similar I cognize what to do," reported 1 interviewee who eyed Black Twitter earlier taking to the streets for a Black Lives Matter protest.

And immoderate usage it for entertainment, chiming successful to co-view "How to Get Away with Murder" oregon "Scandal" (both of which person Black pistillate leads).

As a Black pistillate pursuing a Ph.D. successful a mostly achromatic tract astatine a mostly achromatic university, Klassen has turned to academic-themed hashtags connected Black Twitter to find enactment and comradery from others successful her situation. In the extent of pandemic, a snarky hashtag poking amusive of the Georgia governor's determination to reopen made her laughter retired loud.

"It was a comfortableness to cognize that different radical were taking the pandemic seriously, but besides capable to find wit successful the midst of it," she said.

Culture vultures, voyeurs and racism

But Black Twitter is not without problems, the researchers found.

Users complained of "outsiders" and "voyeurs" who couldn't subordinate to the content, chiming successful to station racist comments, oregon constabulary oregon researchers hovering to stitchery information.

Others complained that contented moderation was not equitable.

"If you are connected the platform, you volition spot achromatic supremacists get distant with saying each kinds of things and ne'er get taken down. But if you are a Black woman, you mightiness get taken down for utilizing African American vernacular English," said Klassen.

Her probe recovered it is not uncommon for "culture vultures" similar BuzzFeed to due tweets from Black Twitter without giving credit. (A akin improvement is happening connected TikTok, wherever the fashionable TikTok dance, Renegade, was created by a Black teen but made celebrated by a achromatic influencer.)

"One of the challenges of platforms similar Twitter, wherever determination are nary subcommunities (like Facebook groups oregon subreddits) is that you person antithetic communities with antithetic societal norms bumping up against 1 another, often successful toxic ways," said Fiesler.

Twitter precocious rolled retired a caller feature, Communities, which whitethorn alteration Black Twitter users to much cautiously curate who tin and cannot spot their content.

Klassen says that's precisely the benignant of betterment her insubstantial is calling for.

But it's lone a start. As idiosyncratic who studied morals and societal justness issues astatine divinity schoolhouse earlier she came here, she sees online communities arsenic a captious resources for underrepresented communities—one which companies should strive to support with the input of their users.

"What would it look similar for Black radical to make their ain spaces oregon astatine slightest beryllium a portion of the instauration process?" she asks. "The aboriginal of online communities for Black and different marginalized radical could laic successful their imaginativeness today."

---

---

More information: Shamika Klassen et al, More than a Modern Day Green Book: Exploring the Online Community of Black Twitter, Proceedings of the ACM connected Human-Computer Interaction (2021). DOI: 10.1145/3479602