Facebook froze as anti-vaccine comments swarmed users

In March, arsenic claims astir the dangers and ineffectiveness of coronavirus vaccines spun crossed societal media and undermined attempts to halt the dispersed of the virus, immoderate Facebook employees thought they had recovered a mode to help.

By subtly altering however posts astir vaccines are ranked successful people's newsfeeds, researchers astatine the institution realized they could curtail the misleading accusation individuals saw astir COVID-19 vaccines and connection users posts from morganatic sources similar the World Health Organization.

"Given these results, I'm assuming we're hoping to motorboat ASAP," 1 Facebook worker wrote successful March, responding to the interior memo astir the study.

Instead, Facebook shelved immoderate suggestions from the study. Other changes weren't made until April.

When different Facebook researcher suggested disabling comments connected vaccine posts successful March until the level could bash a amended occupation of tackling anti-vaccine messages lurking successful them, that connection was ignored.

Critics accidental Facebook was dilatory to enactment due to the fact that it disquieted it mightiness interaction the company's profits.

"Why would you not region comments? Because engagement is the lone happening that matters," said Imran Ahmed, the CEO of the Center for Countering Digital Hate, an net watchdog group. "It drives attraction and attraction equals eyeballs and eyeballs adjacent advertisement revenue."

In an emailed statement, Facebook said it has made "considerable progress" this twelvemonth with downgrading vaccine misinformation successful users' feeds.

Facebook's interior discussions were revealed successful disclosures made to the Securities and Exchange Commission and provided to Congress successful redacted signifier by erstwhile Facebook employee-turned-whistleblower Frances Haugen's ineligible counsel. The redacted versions received by Congress were obtained by a consortium of quality organizations, including The Associated Press.

The trove of documents shows that successful the midst of the COVID-19 pandemic, Facebook cautiously investigated however its platforms dispersed misinformation astir life-saving vaccines. They besides uncover rank-and-file employees regularly suggested solutions for countering anti-vaccine misinformation connected the site, to nary avail. The Wall Street Journal reported connected immoderate of Facebook's efforts to woody with antivaccine comments past month.

The inaction raises questions astir whether Facebook prioritized contention and part implicit the wellness of its users.

"These radical are selling fearfulness and outrage," said Roger McNamee, a Silicon Valley task capitalist and aboriginal capitalist successful Facebook who is present a vocal critic. "It is not a fluke. It is simply a concern model."

Typically, Facebook ranks posts by engagement—the full fig of likes, dislikes, comments and reshares. That ranking strategy whitethorn enactment good for innocuous subjects similar recipes, canine photos oregon the latest viral singalong. But Facebook's ain documents amusement that erstwhile it comes to divisive, contentious issues similar vaccines, engagement-based ranking lone emphasizes polarization, disagreement and doubt.

To survey ways to trim vaccine misinformation, Facebook researchers changed however posts are ranked for much than 6,000 users successful the U.S., Mexico, Brazil and the Philippines. Instead of seeing posts astir vaccines that were chosen based connected their engagement, these users saw posts selected for their trustworthiness.

The results were striking: a astir 12% alteration successful contented that made claims debunked by fact-checkers and an 8% summation successful contented from authoritative nationalist wellness organizations specified arsenic the WHO oregon U.S. Centers for Disease Control.

Employees astatine the institution reacted with exuberance, according to interior exchanges.

"Is determination immoderate crushed we wouldn't bash this?" 1 Facebook worker wrote successful response.

Facebook said it did instrumentality galore of the study's findings—but not for different month, a hold that came astatine a pivotal signifier of the planetary vaccine rollout.

In a statement, institution spokeswoman Dani Lever said the interior documents "don't correspond the sizeable advancement we person made since that clip successful promoting reliable accusation astir COVID-19 and expanding our policies to region much harmful COVID and vaccine misinformation."

The institution besides said it took clip to see and instrumentality the changes.

Yet the request to enactment urgently couldn't person been clearer: At that time, states crossed the U.S. were rolling retired vaccines to their astir vulnerable—the aged and sick. And nationalist wellness officials were worried. Only 10% of the colonisation had received their archetypal dose of a COVID-19 vaccine. And a 3rd of Americans were reasoning astir skipping the changeable entirely, according to a canvass from The Associated Press-NORC Center for Public Affairs Research.

Despite this, Facebook employees acknowledged they had "no idea" conscionable however atrocious anti-vaccine sentiment was successful the comments sections connected Facebook posts. But institution probe successful February recovered that arsenic overmuch arsenic 60% of the comments connected vaccine posts were anti-vaccine oregon vaccine reluctant.

Even worse, institution employees admitted they didn't person a grip connected catching those comments, oregon a argumentation successful spot to instrumentality them down.

"Our quality to observe (vaccine hesitancy) successful comments is atrocious successful English—and fundamentally non-existent elsewhere," different interior memo posted connected March 2 said.

Los Angeles nonmigratory Derek Beres, an writer and fittingness instructor, sees anti-vaccine contented thrive successful the comments each clip helium promotes immunizations connected his accounts connected Instagram, which is owned by Facebook. Last year, Beres began hosting a podcast aft noticing conspiracy theories astir COVID-19 and vaccines were swirling connected the social media feeds of wellness and wellness influencers.

Earlier this year, erstwhile Beres posted a representation of himself receiving the COVID-19 shot, immoderate connected societal media told him helium would apt driblet dormant successful six months' time.

"The comments conception is simply a dumpster occurrence for truthful galore people," Beres said.

Some Facebook employees suggesting disabling each commenting connected vaccine posts portion the institution worked connected a solution.

"Very funny successful your connection to region ALL in-line comments for vaccine posts arsenic a stopgap solution until we tin sufficiently observe vaccine hesitancy successful comments to refine our removal," 1 Facebook worker wrote connected March 2.

The proposition went nowhere.

Instead, Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg announced connected March 15 that the institution would commencement labeling posts astir vaccines that described them arsenic safe.

The determination allowed Facebook to proceed to get precocious engagement—and yet profit—off anti-vaccine comments, said Ahmed of the Center for Countering Digital Hate.

"Facebook has taken decisions which person led to radical receiving misinformation which caused them to die," Ahmed said. "At this point, determination should beryllium a execution investigation."

---

---

© 2021 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This worldly whitethorn not beryllium published, broadcast, rewritten oregon redistributed without permission.