Drivers and hand-held mobile phones: Extending the ban won't solve the problem – here's why

The laws astir mobile telephone usage portion driving are to beryllium tightened nether caller UK authorities plans to marque immoderate usage of a hand-held telephone illegal. From 2022, mobile telephone instrumentality volition beryllium extended to screen taking photos oregon videos, scrolling done playlists oregon playing games portion driving oregon stationary, say, astatine a postulation light. Use of a mobile telephone 'hands-free', however, volition inactive beryllium allowed—even though probe shows it is arsenic distracting.

Currently, UK drivers utilizing a hand-held mobile telephone tin lone beryllium prosecuted if it tin beryllium proven that they were utilizing it for an "interactive communicative function" specified arsenic calling oregon texting. The alteration successful the instrumentality closes this loophole, and makes it easier for distracted drivers to beryllium prosecuted, fined £200, and fixed six points connected their licence.

According to the UK government, 81% of radical who responded to its consultation supported the move. This aligns with findings from roadside breakdown radical RAC, whose annual report connected motoring regularly shows that mobile telephone use by different drivers is simply a apical interest for motorists.

But data besides shows that galore drivers who assertion to enactment the instrumentality nevertheless proceed to usage their phones portion down the wheel. One survey recovered that much than a 4th of drivers admitted to hand-held mobile telephone use, astatine slightest occasionally.

So wherefore bash drivers who enactment the law, and admit the dangers of distracted driving, inactive usage their phones? The reply partially lies successful operator attitudes and biases.

What the grounds tells us

Research consistently shows that astir drivers see themselves to beryllium supra mean astatine driving. Statistically speaking, of course, this is highly unlikely. But this "self-enhancement bias" gives drivers a rationale for believing their mobile telephone usage is safe, portion condemning others for doing the aforesaid thing.

Phone-using drivers justify their behaviour by claiming they are capable to modify their mobile telephone usage babelike connected the driving situation, specified arsenic limiting usage connected engaged roads. They judge they are capable to multitask and mitigate the risk successful a mode that different drivers cannot.

Drivers with self-enhancement bias besides often show "crash hazard optimism"—judging themselves to beryllium astatine little hazard of a clang compared to different drivers.

In a sense, each travel a self-perceived above-average operator successfully completes portion utilizing a mobile telephone appears to corroborate to them that their behaviour is appropriate, and the instrumentality is aimed astatine different drivers. This helps to explicate wherefore beardown enactment for a tightened instrumentality successful this country tin coexist with high rates of offending.

Education campaigns that, for example, diagnostic fatal oregon superior collisions caused by a distracted operator tin really play into these biases. Such campaigns look to corroborate drivers' content that they tin grip it, portion these different "inferior" drivers could not.

For these over-confident drivers, possibly the lone deterrent would beryllium the menace of enforcement. But successful caller years, numbers of dedicated roads-policing officers successful the UK have declined, and the nationalist has, apparently, noticed. In one survey, 54% of respondents felt they were improbable to beryllium caught oregon punished for utilizing a hand-held mobile telephone portion driving.

This operation of circumstances makes it precise hard to transportation drivers that they shouldn't usage their mobile phones down the wheel. If a operator thinks they tin safely multitask portion besides avoiding prosecution, what's stopping them?

We request to alteration attitudes

The tightening of the instrumentality whitethorn assistance to promote immoderate drivers to deliberation astir their telephone use, but it seems improbable it volition lick the occupation of mobile phone usage among drivers, and destruct the harm it causes.

In a broader sense, changes to the instrumentality volition ne'er beryllium capable to support gait with caller technologies. In-vehicle distractions, specified arsenic interactive screens connected the dashboard and integer assistants similar Alexa, are processing much rapidly than the instrumentality tin support up with.

If we privation to trim the number of radical killed and earnestly injured each twelvemonth by drivers utilizing their mobile phones, we person to persuade drivers not to bash it careless of whether oregon not they'll get caught.

We request to situation the narratives that drivers regularly deploy to warrant their behaviour, and code operator biases head-on by providing education, based connected intelligence evidence, that's harder for drivers to defy oregon deny. Interactive education, which allows drivers to acquisition their ain distraction, alternatively than proceeding astir the failures of others, would beryllium a bully spot to start.

If we don't code operator attitudes, we won't meaningfully code operator distraction, careless of what the instrumentality says.

---

---

This nonfiction is republished from The Conversation nether a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.