Deadly auto crashes more likely during pandemic lockdown

With less radical connected the roadworthy during the aboriginal days of the pandemic, much drivers were speeding and driving recklessly, resulting successful much crashes being deadly, a caller survey found.

Researchers astatine The Ohio State University conducted a elaborate investigation of traffic successful Franklin County, Ohio, which includes Columbus, from Feb. 1 to May 8, 2020—the play close earlier and aft COVID-19 stay-at-home orders were instituted by the authorities governor.

While the full fig of collisions declined aft the lockdown, the proportionality of those crashes that were incapacitating oregon fatal much than doubled, results showed.

"More of the crashes that did hap were severe, not conscionable due to the fact that of little congestion, but besides due to the fact that of drivers who were speeding, and driving nether the power of intoxicant oregon drugs," said Jonathan Stiles, pb writer of the survey and a postdoctoral researcher successful geography astatine Ohio State.

Pandemic driving besides led to acold less rear-end collisions and much single-vehicle crashes, findings revealed.

The survey was published this week successful the diary Transportation Research Record and volition look successful a peculiar contented connected COVID-19.

The results uncover a disturbing information astir municipality roadworthy design, said survey co-author Harvey Miller, a prof of geography astatine Ohio State.

"This is much grounds that our streets are designed for speed, not safety," said Miller, who is besides manager of Ohio State's Center for Urban and Regional Analysis.

"What is keeping crashes from being much terrible during mean times is higher volumes of traffic, and erstwhile postulation goes away, radical velocity and crashes person much superior consequences."

The researchers collected clang and postulation measurement information for Franklin County from the Ohio Department of Public Safety.

They utilized accusation from INRIX, a backstage proscription information company, showing real-time speeds connected assorted segments of large roads and highways successful the county.

In summation to the real-time speeds, INRIX calculates a notation velocity for each roadworthy segment, which is the mean velocity for that conception erstwhile determination is nary large traffic. It is usually adjacent to the velocity limit.

Stay-at-home policies were instituted successful Ohio connected March 15 and continued done the extremity of the survey connected May 8.

Traffic volumes declined by much than 60% portion the stay-at-home bid was successful effect, the survey showed. Vehicle crashes changed successful type, clip of time and severity erstwhile compared to some the play close earlier the lockdown, arsenic good arsenic the aforesaid 55-day play successful 2019.

The bully quality is that crashes were overmuch little predominant successful Franklin County nether the stay-at-home period, averaging lone 24.4 per time compared to 75.8 successful the anterior year.

Collisions were besides little prevalent during the greeting and day unreserved hours, compared to the aforesaid play successful 2019.

Rear-end collisions accounted for lone 19% of crashes during the lockdown, compared to 35.5% a twelvemonth earlier, portion the proportionality of single-vehicle crashes astir doubled, from 12.9% to 25.3%

"Rear-end collisions thin to hap erstwhile you person a batch of postulation connected the roads and that's 1 happening we didn't person during this COVID-19 period," Stiles said.

"But determination was a batch much speed. Single-vehicle crashes are thing you would beryllium much apt to spot erstwhile a operator is traveling astatine precocious velocity and loses control."

Crashes successful which the reporting serviceman cited speeding arsenic a origin astir doubled nether the stay-at-home orders compared to the erstwhile year. In an earlier study, immoderate of the aforesaid researchers recovered that speeding by drivers much than tripled successful Columbus erstwhile comparing 2020 to pre-pandemic 2019.

In addition, much crashes during the lockdown were linked by constabulary to intoxicant and cause use.

And much speeding and cause and intoxicant usage meant much superior crashes. Results showed 3.3% of collisions during the lockdown play were incapacitating oregon fatal, compared to 1.5% the erstwhile year.

"The likelihood of a superior crash were inactive comparatively low, but those chances accrued importantly with little postulation and higher speeds connected the roads," said survey co-author Armita Kar, a doctoral pupil successful geography astatine Ohio State.

The results person implications for information and equity, the researchers said.

One contented is that indispensable workers, who are often low-income and minorities, were the ones astir apt to beryllium connected the road.

"These indispensable workers had to get to their jobs, truthful they are the ones who were exposed to the hazard of much unsafe collisions," Miller said.

"Of course, sometimes the collisions were their ain fault, but not always."

There's besides the question of what bash with roads if postulation volumes diminution permanently due to the fact that of much radical moving from home—or successful the lawsuit of different exigency that keeps astir radical from driving.

"If there's little traffic, galore of our roads whitethorn beryllium wider than they person to be, which encourages speeding," Stiles said. "There's a information tradeoff."

Cities should see implementing proven strategies for slowing traffic, including having less lanes successful metro areas, according to the researchers.

"We request to redesign streets and roads with information successful caput and not conscionable speed," Miller said.

---

---

More information: Jonathan Stiles et al, Lower Volumes, Higher Speeds: Changes to Crash Type, Timing, and Severity connected Urban Roads from COVID-19 Stay-at-Home Policies, Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board (2021). DOI: 10.1177/03611981211044454